Stats
By the numbers: ratings, records, and runtime
Total Episode Runtime
72 hours, 41 minutes
Total Film Runtime
102 hours, 56 minutes
Steve's Rating Distribution
Nic's Rating Distribution
How We Compare
Agreement Rate
31.6%
Gave the same rating
Steve's Avg
3.77/5
Average rating
Nic's Avg
3.85/5
Average rating
Biggest Gap
2.5
Point difference
Biggest Disagreements
Films where Steve and Nic had the most different opinions
Toy Soldiers
Pacific Heights
The Last Starfighter
Thief
Perfect Agreement
Films where Steve and Nic gave the exact same rating
The Fugitive
Army of Darkness
The River Wild
Rounders
Demolition Man
Sneakers
Starship Troopers
Jacob's Ladder
The Thing
The Silence of the Lambs
Halloween III: Season of the Witch
Con Air
Die Hard
Total Recall
True Lies
Strange Brew
The Breakfast Club
GoodFellas
Dads vs Critics
How do Steve and Nic's ratings compare to Rotten Tomatoes?
Critics' Choice
Films where the Dads and critics both agreed they were great
The Fugitive
The Silence of the Lambs
Die Hard
GoodFellas
Ghostbusters
Terminator 2: Judgment Day
The Thing
A Nightmare on Elm Street
Trading Places
This Is Spinal Tap
Face/Off
Indiana Jones and the Last Crusade
Raising Arizona
The Breakfast Club
Total Recall
Sneakers
Universally Panned
Films where the Dads and critics both agreed they were bad
Halloween III: Season of the Witch
Rocky IV
Brewster's Millions
Road House
Pacific Heights
Contrarian Corner
Films critics loved that the Dads didn't
Thief
Box Office Records
Highest Profit
Home Alone
$458,000,000
Budget: $18,000,000
Box Office: $476,000,000
Lowest Profit
Strange Brew
-$2,100,000
Budget: $4,000,000
Box Office: $1,900,000
Highest ROI
The Breakfast Club
+5050.0%
Budget: $1,000,000
Box Office: $51,500,000
Lowest ROI
Strange Brew
-52.5%
Budget: $4,000,000
Box Office: $1,900,000
Rating Extremes
Lowest RT
Brewster's Millions, Rocky IV
39%
Highest RT
Airplane!
97%
Lowest IMDb
Halloween III: Season of the Witch
5.2
Highest IMDb
GoodFellas
8.7
Siskel & Ebert Tracker
Classic critics' opinions on the films we've covered
Siskel 👍
26
Siskel 👎
31
Ebert 👍
31
Ebert 👎
26
Two Thumbs Up 👍👍
Films both Siskel and Ebert loved (16 total)
Groundhog Day
The Fugitive
Rounders
Terminator 2: Judgment Day
The Naked Gun: From the Files of Police Squad!
This Is Spinal Tap
Cape Fear
Jacob's Ladder
Face/Off
Trading Places
Airplane!
Thief
Ghostbusters
The Breakfast Club
Wall Street
GoodFellas
Two Thumbs Down 👎👎
Films both Siskel and Ebert panned (16 total)
Toy Soldiers
Pacific Heights
Army of Darkness
The River Wild
Brewster's Millions
Happy Gilmore
They Live
Friday
The Secret of My Success
Tommy Boy
A Nightmare on Elm Street
Home Alone
Fast Times at Ridgemont High
Strange Brew
Beetlejuice
Road House
Steve & Nic vs Siskel & Ebert
How often do the Dads agree with Siskel and Ebert? (3+ = 👍, 2.5- = 👎)
Steve + Siskel
45.6%
Steve + Ebert
61.4%
Nic + Siskel
52.6%
Nic + Ebert
57.9%